commadot.com http://commadot.com UX = User Experience Tue, 12 Sep 2017 17:12:31 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.8-RC2-40880 https://i0.wp.com/commadot.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/cropped-siteIcon21.png?fit=32%2C32 commadot.com http://commadot.com 32 32 2075023 LinkedIn’s Windows 10 App http://commadot.com/linkedins-windows-10-app/ http://commadot.com/linkedins-windows-10-app/#respond Tue, 12 Sep 2017 17:12:31 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=7067 Read More »]]> I use Windows 10.

But Glen, you are a designer, why don’t you use Macs?!? – Everyone

Here are my answers since everyone brings it up:

  1. I’ve been using Microsoft operating systems since 1986. I’ve beta tested every OS they have ever released including Windows ME (Yuck!)
  2. Most of the world (and about 35% of my users ) have Windows. All of the engineers here use Macs, so SOMEONE should be looking at the product the way that our customers do.
  3. I see no benefit to switching. The Mac
    1. doesn’t have better software for me,
    2. isn’t faster for me,
    3. doesn’t have better peripherals for me,
    4. isn’t a better UX for me.

I think too many people (sheeple!) follow the trends. It doesn’t matter if you use Linux, Windows, Chromebook or Mac. Use whatever you are comfortable with and gets the job done.

OK, but the point of this blog post are Windows 10 apps. Again, I have used Windows for 30+ years and I can confidently say:

Windows 10 Apps are stupid – Glen Lipka

I’m sorry, they are just terrible. They are like Microsoft Bob. A cute interesting experiment, but ultimately, a bad idea. Hardly anyone uses them on regular basis, especially in a work environment.

So why did LinkedIn make a Windows app?  Well, I guess the answer is obvious. Because they got acquired by Microsoft, duh. However, look at the details of the app. Here they are, side-by-side:

If I am using a mouse on a laptop with a monitor, then there really is no benefit. It’s just the regular site in a special window. I don’t want that. I can’t use my chrome extensions in the Windows app world.

The only benefit is if I am running Windows on a tablet. Then the touch targets are bigger and (slightly) more compatible. Still, this seems like a waste of time.

LinkedIn is the default resume website of the world. It’s a virtual monopoly. They can do whatever they want and still not get disrupted. That makes product development especially tricky. Innovation is difficult when you have a monopoly. There is only one direction to go, down. So it makes sense that they deliver this useless app. However, innovation is possible. It has to be.

My plea to LinkedIn is to try hard to innovate. Open up your APIs, be bold and experimental. Try and solve the “org chart problem”. Do something ambitious. Don’t just pop your website into a shell and call it an app. You can do better than that.

Well, I have hope that you can.

]]>
http://commadot.com/linkedins-windows-10-app/feed/ 0 7067
I miss Skeuomorphism http://commadot.com/i-miss-skeuomorphism/ http://commadot.com/i-miss-skeuomorphism/#comments Mon, 11 Sep 2017 15:56:03 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=7059 Read More »]]>

Skeuomorphism is the design concept of making items represented resemble their real-world counterparts. (Examples)

Im in Windows → Chrome → WordPress and almost all of the shadows, gradients and rounded corners have been eliminated.

These are buttons.

The tiniest possible shadow and rounded corner. 1px each.

I miss buttons that had heft and affordance that screamed Click Me.

Mmmm. Skeuo!

The Nielsen-Norman group recent published a study that found significant reduction in task completion because of flat design. I know design fashion is a real thing that makes a difference, but I think flat design has had its time and now we need to bring back rounded corners, shadows and gradients. Bring back affordance!

Affordance is when an object’s sensory characteristics intuitively imply its functionality and use. (More detail)

I am not proposing something ugly, but we need to move forward. The number one thing to start with is shadows. Shadows provide enormous hints to the information architecture and drag-ability of an object. It creates layers of information. Enough with the 1px thin line. Let’s see some real separation of layers.

Take it all the way

Sometimes I hear the words “clean, classic, modern, fresh” and then I see “flat, white, undifferentiated, boring”. I see low task completion rates.

Well, bottom line…I miss that 3-dimensionality. Blur the lines of digital and physical. Keep it beautiful, but experiment.

]]>
http://commadot.com/i-miss-skeuomorphism/feed/ 1 7059
Teaching Excel in High School http://commadot.com/teaching-excel-in-high-school/ http://commadot.com/teaching-excel-in-high-school/#comments Tue, 05 Sep 2017 15:58:02 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=7056 Read More »]]> My kids are in middle and high school. They are learning math at different levels. The thing that annoys me is how little they use Excel to do their work. Why do we teach kids how to calculate by hand? Think of the alternative:

  1. Start teaching excel early like kindergarden
  2. Accelerate through simple subjects like addition and subtraction
  3. Start to give harder problems to solve that require multiple cells with advanced math like geometry
  4. Make tests where you need to solve problems in Excel and “show your work” by breaking the problem down into discrete cells
  5. Super advanced levels – use macros to teach programming

Excel, for better or worse, drives a huge amount of work in this world. Startups model their entire business in excel. People project manage in Excel. Excel is one of the killer productivity apps of the last 50 years. Why is it possible to graduate high school and not be fluent in it?

I think teaching excel would increase mathematics retention and advancement. It would spur more programming careers. It would spur more innovation in business modeling.

I am not saying that it would solve the Korean nuclear threat…but maybe it would!

Who is in charge of this sort of thing? How can our entire mathematics curriculum system in public schools be changed?  is that even possible?

Can anything change? My kids learn math the same way I did 30 years ago.

Even if we know the answers, are we just doomed to repeat the past?

]]>
http://commadot.com/teaching-excel-in-high-school/feed/ 1 7056
The End of Trust http://commadot.com/the-end-of-trust/ http://commadot.com/the-end-of-trust/#respond Tue, 15 Aug 2017 23:58:57 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=7012 Read More »]]> I listened to a Radiolab podcast recently about some new technologies. One is called Adobe Voco. Voco allows you to easily manipulate audio of another person. You can even make someone say something they never said before. The other technology lets you create a video of someone saying something they have never said before. Sort of like video puppetry. (See example)

Without going into the details, this kind of technology can be used to create fake audio or video. Remember that “Grab em by the pussy” audio of Donald Trump? If that happened today, I bet he would claim that it’s “fake audio”. It’s Voco.

So if I can’t trust audio and I can’t trust video and I can’t trust what I read…what can I trust? Only what I see with my own eyes?

The world is getting more and more skeptical of “facts” and “science” for exactly this reason. Our trust has been misplaced and misused so many times that we can’t believe anything at all. Is the world round? Is Climate Change real? I don’t even know if I exist or am just a virtual being in a SIM game.

And yet, I have hope. Right now, there is a steady stream of fake news and confirmation bias on the web. I think this is making us sick. Like a virus, it is attacking our ability to live and be sane. Also, like a virus, we will build up antibodies. We will build up an immune system. It may take a generation, but we survive this plague of lies and misinformation. A future generation will understand what is real and what is not. They will do more research and understand how to balance out conflicting information. They will become savvy.

I have hope in the future that although blind trust may be completely lost, qualified trust may be restored.

If not, then I am afraid that we will spiral into a chaotic mess. Hopefully, civilization is up to the task.

 

 

]]>
http://commadot.com/the-end-of-trust/feed/ 0 7012
A funny thing happened on the way to the domain server http://commadot.com/a-funny-thing-happened-on-the-way-to-the-domain-server/ http://commadot.com/a-funny-thing-happened-on-the-way-to-the-domain-server/#comments Tue, 25 Jul 2017 16:27:14 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=7006 Read More »]]> Marketo forgot to pay their domain bill to Network Solutions. Thus their entire service went down today.

Keep in mind, this is a billion dollar company which is part of a 10+ billion dollar private equity firm. There are over 1,200 people who work there. How could this happen?

Well, the reality is that it’s quite easy. Here is the formula:

  1. Lose alot of employees including managers over a short period of time

It’s a simple formula, I know. However, this is how things go awry. When architects leave the engineering team, the architecture falls apart. When designers leave the UX team, the consistency of the app falls apart. When managers leave, institutional knowledge evaporates. This isn’t specific to Marketo. Lots of companies, big and small, have had this problem. It threatens the very existence of the company.

So why don’t companies put systems in place to avoid this? Again, the answer is simple: Because it’s hard and costs money. It’s much easier to assume things will be OK. It’s much easier to assume things will remain the same.

An object in motion tends to stay in motion and an object at rest tends to stay at rest.  In other words, a domain name that is registered tends to stay registered.

We all act surprised when shit hits the fan because we are hard wired to assume that the status quo is permanent. This is why I love startups. Before you have customers or code that can go down, you are just building something new. Before even engineering kicks in, you have just designs on a piece of paper.

Side note: Accidentally losing your domain used to be worse. Someone would swoop in and buy it. Now Network Solutions holds it for some time to let you renew. It avoids lawsuits and is a much better system.

]]>
http://commadot.com/a-funny-thing-happened-on-the-way-to-the-domain-server/feed/ 5 7006
Grinding http://commadot.com/grinding/ http://commadot.com/grinding/#respond Thu, 06 Jul 2017 21:11:41 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=7000 Read More »]]> There are particular kinds of games where you have to spend alot of time doing simple things to get your level up. An example is killing a million squirrels in the forest so you can buy the sword to go after a dragon in a cave. This technique is called grinding.

Some games specialize in this kind of play. The psychology is pretty interesting. It clearly hits a part of my brain that is difficult to shut off. I feel like I can’t stop grinding. Madden NFL Mobile has a serious grinding mentality. I find myself needing to do it at night before I go to sleep. I know that reading a book is better for me, but I think I have some DNA that predisposes to grinding.

I think I grind in real life too. Creating Docs.marketo.com took 3 years of grinding. Designing and building a product is also a grind. You add one feature at a time to build a whole over the course of years.

Another example of this is the Primitive Technology video series. I love watching these videos. They calm the inner part of my soul. This guy is in the woods and builds things with his hands, rocks, water and trees.

To build something great you have to build a series of little things first. Being a great professional in any job means doing the same thing. It means grinding towards that future. Build up your assets one piece at a time.

When people talk about grit, I think of that as the ability to grind. I think they are two sides of the same coin.

What ruins grinding is when you perceive other people succeeding without it. Maybe they “knew the right person” or maybe they were better looking or maybe they just got lucky. I have heard plenty of stories of people making millions without contributing towards that success. One guy joined Marketo a few weeks before all the stock was fast-forwarded and vested and paid out. He made millions and quit a few weeks later. Totally lucky and unfair, but such is life.

I could dwell on this, but it would only make me unhappy. Rather, I should focus on the grind in front of me. Build something great, keep building. I don’t think of grinding as unpleasant. It actually makes me feel focused. I am moving the ball forward each day.

]]>
http://commadot.com/grinding/feed/ 0 7000
An ABM Adventure http://commadot.com/an-abm-adventure/ http://commadot.com/an-abm-adventure/#respond Wed, 21 Jun 2017 16:51:51 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=6990 Read More »]]> I am Head of Product for Engagio, a SaaS application with lots of features and users who use them. (Is there any other type of SaaS application?)

Warning: This blog post throws data around the web with total abandon and gets confusing. You have been warned.

My Mission: To activate and spur usage in the system.

First Step: Usage Tracking
If you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it. (Thanks, Avinash for that lesson over 10 years ago.) We use Pendo for application usage tracking and other stuff. We spent a few weeks tagging every feature in the app and rolling up those features so we can have usage charts like this:

Users –> Contacts
The next step was to get users from the application into Salesforce. This required some engineering help (Thanks, Shaun and Abhishek!). We had some issues with parsing Full Name into First and Last Name. Plus we ended up with some duplicates before we tweaked the system to get it just right. Finally, all users were automatically created in Salesforce as contacts.

Segmentation
I wanted to focus on the group of people that I would have the most success with. I thought the Sales users with some usage in one part of the product but not the other would perfect. However, I didn’t have everything I needed to do that. We used a series of partners, ClearBit, UpWork, LinkedIn, and their user profile to create a field called Best Title.

By using Marketo, we automatically had those contacts sync down to the marketing automation system. I used a smart campaign to use all of those possible titles to create one field called Best Title. Then I used the Marketo Segmentation tool to group different titles into departments. Sales, Marketing, Ops, Executives, etc. I still have some that defy interpretation. However, I had my department segment.

Usage Fields
We created several different fields in Salesforce/Marketo called Pendo (Feature) Usage 7d.  I chose 7 days as a decent measurement of activity, but I imagine we will need 14 or 30 days in the future. I also created definitions for Alive (Normal Use), Dead (No Use) and Life Support (Minimal Use).

Last Mile for the Data
Finally, we figured out how to pump the usage data from Pendo into Salesforce which would sync down to Marketo. I could then make smart lists of the different segment/usage patterns and craft a report that had roles and usage in a matrix. Also, I could pick the particular segment I wanted. (Sales users with one product use, but not another.)

Taking Action
I didn’t just want to send a mail blast to these users. What would be the point? You can’t spur action with a generic message. It has to be specific. This is where we come full circle back into Engagio. I created a Play to reach out to this segment. It wasn’t super complicated.

  • Step 1: A personalized email
  • Step 2: Wait for a week and check their usage
  • Step 3: LinkedIn connection request

By setting up a trigger, I could have this play automatically kicked off and give me tasks to do. The email looked/felt/was totally hand-written, but the system lets me scale that effort to reach more people easier. Plus, it kept track of who I reached out to so I could follow up without needing to create a bunch of tasks in my calendar.

Results
I just got started with this initiative, but so far I have a 50% reply rate. Not click rate or open rate. This is a REPLY!  Most of the replies have indicated that they were unaware of the feature. I follow up with each person to see how we can get them aware. Plus, I am working with our onboarding team to make sure we focus on awareness in the product rollout.

Account Based Journeys
Everyone knows Top of Funnel. This is going on a journey from never having heard of a product to closing the sale. You can break this down into funnels like Aware, MQA (Marketing Qualified Account), SQA (Sales Qualified Account), Opportunity, Closed-Won. In addition, there are other journeys such as:

  • Onboarding
  • Healthy Usage
  • Advocacy
  • Renewal
  • Up-sell/Cross-sell

Each journey involves coordination/orchestration, communication (phone, email, direct mail), sales and messaging. Each journey does their job in a slightly different way, although they all share common characteristics. The one I was working on was Healthy Usage. I was using Sales, Marketing and Product functionality. I consider these systems to reside in the same “cloud”. Data should move fluidly from one system to the next.

I think this little adventure is hard for people to wrap their heads around, but the results are important. I believe Marketers need to wrap their heads around projects like this if they want to expand their career horizons and become more strategic. Hopefully, you found it useful and entertaining.

]]>
http://commadot.com/an-abm-adventure/feed/ 0 6990
Why I eat food http://commadot.com/why-i-eat-food/ http://commadot.com/why-i-eat-food/#respond Fri, 09 Jun 2017 16:19:11 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=6975 Read More »]]> I can think of five reasons I eat food.

  1. Hunger
  2. Boredom
  3. It tastes good
  4. Food is in front of me
  5. Other people are eating in front of me

Hunger
I almost never eat food because I’m hungry. When I was 17 I was hungry all the time. I could eat ALL DAY. However, this has waned for me in recent decades. I don’t think I have been truly hungry all year. I know there are plenty of people in the world who are hungry. I am just not one of them. Let’s call this 0%.

Boredom
I’d say I eat because of boredom about 5% of the time. Not that often, and it usually is on the weekends if I am by myself. It kills time and is something to do.

It tastes good
This is true for probably 20% of all my food. Specifically, if I make a meal and it’s too much food, I will keep eating until it’s gone. Maybe it’s my heritage that I was brought up to not waste food, but I have alot of trouble stopping mid-meal. In most restaurants, the portion size is twice what I truly need. Finishing meals is not a virtue.

Food is in front of me
Let’s say I am at a party and there are hors d’ ordres being served. I will eat it even if it tasted bad. It’s one of those things where the food calls out to you like a Greek siren in Odysseus. This isn’t all that often, maybe another 5%.

Other people are eating in front of me
Let’s call it 70% of the time, I eat because it’s a social setting like a family dinner or team lunch. I can’t just sit at a table while other people eat. Even if the food is terrible, even if I am not hungry, I will at least pick at the food. I went to a family event on the east coast last month and they had all kinds of eating moments. Pre-party, morning brunch, lunch, dinner, etc etc etc. I found myself eating WAY more than normal. Most of the food I eat is in social situations. When I am alone for a day or two, I eat less. My doctor said that “3 square meals a day” a fiction foisted on us by lobbyists of farmers and other food industry companies. They wanted to sell more food. We don’t need three meals a day. We are actually fine with just one.

DISCLAIMER
None of this is meant as a diet or a suggestion of how to lose weight. It’s just an introspective look at myself. I find looking at details of one’s life is an excellent exercise for the designer’s mind.

Update
At the beginning of the year, I had this weird thing where I wasn’t very hungry. I started losing weight because I was eating about half as much food. I have had no other symptoms since then. I think that last year, I ate for the same reasons as above, but I just had no desire to stop. I just kept stuffing food in until I couldn’t eat another bite. Since losing weight, I have tried to make it a habit to avoid eating as much as I did previously. I hope that habit will stick for the long term.

 

]]>
http://commadot.com/why-i-eat-food/feed/ 0 6975
Sphere of Influence, Control, Concern http://commadot.com/sphere-of-influence-control-concern/ http://commadot.com/sphere-of-influence-control-concern/#respond Tue, 06 Jun 2017 01:38:35 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=6965 Read More »]]> An interesting way to frame an employee is by spheres, specifically three of them:

  • Sphere of Control is the stuff you can decide on your own. This is people you manage and project you do the work personally.
  • Sphere of Influence is stuff that you can guide through collaboration or subtle techniques. Your friendly co-worker is part of your sphere of influence.
  • Sphere of Concern is stuff you care about but you have no way to influence it. This might be happenings in other departments in which you don’t have strong connections.

Let’s take a look at some different circle widths and how they change things.

The Influencer
These are the best people in an organization. They don’t control a whole lot, but they influence a ton of things. Product Managers usually have little managerial control, but work with many people in the company. In general, you want people like this. However, they can get very unhappy if their sphere of influence diminishes. I used to be a person like this at Marketo. I had the ear of many of my fellow co-workers. Unfortunately, under one of my less favorite bosses, my influence slowly melted away. (long frustrating story) That left me in the state of the next archetype.

The Complainer
I became the complainer because I had this little tiny sphere of control, not much smaller than my sphere if influence. Most people hate to be in this position, and I certainly did. The problem with this diagram is that the sphere of concern is enormous, but the person can’t do anything about it.

The Individual Contributor
See how much better this is? They have the same influence and control as above, but they have a much smaller sphere of concern. They are happy because their world is smaller and their ability to influence their sphere of concern is “proportional”. That’s a key insight here. Proportionality is the key to success and happiness. Don’t let your sphere widths get out of whack.

The Group Manager
Of course, you can give someone more power, more control by promoting them and giving them many people to manage. If they have a circle like the following then I would propose they should care more about the other areas of the company.

The Perfect Balance
The best situation is when you balance out people’s aspirations of concern and their influence and control. You generally want people to be influential, but not at the cost of their own areas or their sanity.

Is this blog post the most wisdom filled block of text I ever wrote? Probably not, but they can’t all be zingers. I need to keep it balanced!

]]>
http://commadot.com/sphere-of-influence-control-concern/feed/ 0 6965
The Sweet Spot http://commadot.com/the-sweet-spot/ http://commadot.com/the-sweet-spot/#respond Wed, 31 May 2017 19:54:02 +0000 http://commadot.com/?p=6959 Read More »]]> There are many manifestations of the sweet spot.  Some examples:

Product Strategy
In this image, the sweet spot is avoiding competition while also focusing on what you do best. If you focus on the customer needs and ignore your own capabilities then you run the risk of failure to execute. If you only focus on what you can achieve, you might not find a market. If you drift too close to the competitors it creates other problems.

Sports
This image of a gold club shows how hitting the wrong part of the club yields a bad shot. There really isn’t alot of space for doing it right. You either hit the sweet spot or you have a lousy shot. I find tennis has the same effect.

Your Career
It’s tough to manage your career, but this chart shows how many people end up unhappy. Each circle is important and you need to balance them out.

 

Marketing
I’ve seen marketing go awry hundreds of times. My first product had terrible marketing despite being a good technology. I’ve also seen the opposite. The sweet spot is a balance.

One might argue that you can’t have it all. The sweet spot isn’t trying to magically be great at everything. It’s a worldview, an approach to life that says not to be extreme. Don’t just focus on one issue. Balance the issues out.

One might argue that this will lead to Jack of All Trades, Master of None syndrome. Although this is possible, I think it’s not a bad outcome. I love people who can do lots of things. Being a utility player, someone who can be flexible is important. That doesn’t mean you are bad at everything, but you don’t have to sacrifice other good things and obsess just about the one.

Balance in life, balance at play, balance at work.  That is the true sweet spot.

]]>
http://commadot.com/the-sweet-spot/feed/ 0 6959