A Big Problem #boycottSafari

Note: This post is fairly technical, using (without explaining) many marketing concepts. It has a big impact, but may be complex for many people, especially designers.

Many people in the world would prefer that everything online be free AND that their privacy is ironclad. The problem is that this ignores the economics of how everything we use on the internet is funded. The simple answer is Advertising and Marketing. And Apple just threw a monkey wrench into the whole shebang.

What specifically is changing?

It’s called Intelligent Tracking Prevention 2.1. Apple, makers of Safari based on Webkit, are changing the way that cookies are stored. Specifically, they changed the expiration date of all client-side cookies to 7 days.

With this update we further reduce trackers’ ability to establish user identities across sites.

Feb 29, 2019, Apple

Who does that effect?

This will be felt by every single marketing department in the world. Cookies, in short, have been a key element of trillions of dollars of economic activity in the past 20 years. Many business systems depend on these little files in ways most people don’t fully understand. Let’s look at a common example:

A mid-sized business (150 people) buys a marketing automation platform (Marketo, Pardot, Hubspot, etc) and uses a CRM (Salesforce, MS Dynamics, etc). The marketing automation system comes with a little JavaScript line which they put on their site. One default lifespan of these cookies is 730 days. When a prospect visits the company site, they are tracked in both the sales and marketing systems via this cookie. These visits turn into Lead Scoring so that Sales and SDRs focus on the people who are most likely to convert into a sale. Tracking is also important for Attribution which helps marketers decide how to spend next years marketing budget.

Then, let’s say the anonymous visitor fills out a form to download a whitepaper. Now, the marketer knows who the person is (via the form info) and can de-duplicate and tailor messages to that person based on their activity. This is standard Marketing Automation 101.

Now, if they are using Safari, those cookies are not persistent for 730 days, but rather only 7 days. Lead scoring for anonymous activity will become useless. Abandoned (deleted cookies) anonymous leads will pile up in every marketing automation system leading to performance issues.

Next issue is advertising. Advertising is a big, complicated, incestuous business. When you see an ad somewhere, it is traveling through dozens of lightning fast servers, each adding a bit of information to yield the correct ad. When you search for something on Google or Amazon and then visit other sites, you will likely see that item advertised. It’s called re-targeting.

Now you might think this technique is creepy and an intrusion of privacy. However, try to understand is that the website they are visiting doesn’t exist for charity. They exist to make money. When you use an ad-blocker or when Safari drops these cookies, they are inherently making those websites less profitable. We live in a capitalist world. People work to make money. Businesses hire employees to make money. Money makes the internet work. Limiting advertising may sound good, but it directly impacts the ability of sites to produce “free” content.

Who is immune to this?

Several companies are immune to this because it doesn’t affect the kind of cookie you use to login to a system. So Amazon can track you because you are logged in. Same with the Apple store, Google, Netflix, Twitter, Facebook, and any system where you are logged in.

Unfortunately, this doesn’t help the hundreds of thousands of businesses worldwide who use marketing automation or advertising networks to get the word out about their products and services.

What do we do about this?

I think we should boycott Safari. Yes, this is an unlikely thing to protest when we have global climate change to worry about. However, we still need jobs and we still love free content. We need to support this thing that gives so many of us a reason to work.

My suggestion would be to popup a message to safari users saying, “This site uses cookies to give you a good experience. Safari makes that very difficult. Your experience would be better if you switched to Chrome.”


There are many other elements of this story. How does Google respond? This affects Google Analytics, how will they change? Will there be more paywalls for content erected? This is not a good story, but I will try and keep an eye on it.

3 responses to “A Big Problem #boycottSafari”

  1. If you weren’t involved in the particular business of internet marketing, would you still feel the same way? If your EZ pass (or whatever they use for tolls in CA) tracks all your movements and sold that data, would that be ok. Regular TV doesn’t track the channels, but Netflix does, is it ok for them to sell that data. What about the government (or foreign governments) who are definitely tracking this information. Although for me, the issue isn’t collecting the data, it is who they are selling it to? Is the benefit to corporations (more profits) greater than the risk of the data being misused. Or the value of privacy? I think it comes to proactive or reactive use. If you are using the data to see a reaction to something, that seems reasonable. However, if you are using the data to manipulate people into doing something, that has the potential for abuse. Perhaps the solution would be an opt-in, where if people want a service, they have to opt-in to be tracked in return for their cookies.

    As a product, what is the benefit for apple to track these cookies? Will it increase the user experience? Does Apple have a responsibility to the greater marketing world to continue an important part of the online economy?

  2. “Limiting advertising may sound good, but it directly impacts the ability of sites to produce “free” content.”

    That’s fine. I personally think the world would be better off without all the “free” content that people consume these days, when it comes to news, for instance. If I have to start paying a dollar or two to access a website, fine.

    • Many sites and services have tried and failed to implement pay walls. They don’t work, not enough people are willing to pay. Advertising funds literally millions of jobs. They would just disappear.

      I dare you to avoid using any service that relies on ads for a month. No free email. No search engine, no social media, no games with ads, no websites with ads. Let me know how that goes.

Whatya think?

%d bloggers like this: