One day in 1869, two friends, Pierre-Auguste Renoir and Claude Monet, visited La Grenouillère and painted the same scene side-by side. Here there are:
As you can see, there were in the same spot at the same time. They were both accomplished French impressionists. They were both the same age (born 4 months apart). One would think they would paint similar things. However, I think their paintings show a key insight about human nature.
Monet’s Impression
Monet saw the water. The people and landscape were secondary. He moved them out of the way so he could focus on the undulating water and interplay with the shadows and light. The water, although impressionistic, is almost realism with how he captured the feel of it. When looking at the painting, one is drawn into the water leaving a sense of natural beauty and peace.
Renoir’s Impression
Renoir saw a lively interaction of people. He zooms in, adds people, adds movement and interaction. These people are the focus of the painting. Even the tan boat is being tugged by a little boy. The tree, water, and landscape are there to frame the people. In Monet, the people frame the water. One is left seeing the Renoir with a feeling of bustling activity and fun.
Imagine giving a sound track to both paintings. The Monet would have the sound of the water, slightly splashing with the sound of wind rustling through the trees. Voices could be heard in the background. The Renoir would be the sound of people laughing and talking. It’s not hard to imagine the difference just by looking at the images.
Art and Life
This little demonstration helps to understand that everyone sees something different in every interaction. What you think is funny or wonderful, might give revulsion to another and vice versa. Right and wrong are not always cut and dry. I think we (as a society) get ourselves into trouble when we lack empathy for the point of view of the others.
It’s not easy to see someone else’s point of view. We are each trapped in our own heads. Yet we can imagine. We can imagine what it is like in the shoes of others.
In the coming years, we may have to face existential challenges. There will be differing perspectives. I hope we can keep open minds and hearts as we navigate the waters, and the people.
Whatya think?